Grand Theft Auto 6 received a Metacritic score of 99 out of 100 from aggregated critic reviews, tying it with Nintendo's The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for the highest score since 1998.
Gaming outlets offered near-universal praise. IGN called it "unprecedented," "unbelievable" and "unmissable." Eurogamer's five-star review said Rockstar had "pushed back the horizon of video games." Bloomberg's Jason Schreier termed it a "masterpiece." The Washington Post said it "raises the bar at every level."
Critics highlighted the game's graphics, with The Guardian describing the Miami-inspired setting of Leonida as "so lifelike that at times it beggars belief." The relationship between lead characters Jason and Lucia drew particular attention. The Guardian's Keza MacDonald wrote they "feel like real people rather than puppets dancing to your whim." Forbes' Paul Tassi said he had "never seen a better video game relationship."
Some reviewers noted trade-offs. The New York Times' Yussef Cole observed the game had "matured beyond its memorable car crashes and stickups" with consequences to every action, though he said he still enjoyed careening through streets in pursuit. Gaming journalist Jordan Middler, who played for about 100 hours, found the game can "slow down" because of how much is occurring.
The Game Awards nominated GTA 6 for eight prizes despite it not having been released at nomination time, making it the most-nominated title. The best performance nomination of actress Manni L Perez unofficially confirmed she voices Lucia, a fact Rockstar had not previously disclosed.
Some online posters questioned whether hype around the game had become excessive, with one commenting the game is overhyped.