The UK's Covid inquiry found that early containment efforts "were doomed to fail" because the test, trace and isolate system could handle only a small number of cases, according to the seventh report released this week. The virus spread virtually unchecked for months after community testing and contact tracing stopped in mid-March 2020, the inquiry said, costing lives.
Inquiry chair Baroness Hallett said the UK should have been better prepared. Unlike Hong Kong, South Korea, Singapore and Taiwan, which had established systems ready, the UK had abandoned its capacity despite running simulation exercises including Exercise Cygnus and Exercise Alice that identified problems with testing, tracing and isolation.
The report criticises the government for not having a robust system in place from the start, saying this meant harsher measures including lockdown and school closures became necessary. More than £30 billion was spent on testing, tracing and isolating across the UK during the pandemic. NHS Test and Trace launched two months after March 2020 and eventually became one of the largest testing services per head of population.
The four UK nations were "effectively blind" to how quickly Covid was spreading in early months, the inquiry found. It raises whether the government could have used non-government testing facilities in hospitals, universities and the private sector instead of relying only on 12 government labs.
The inquiry found the UK lacked a clear strategy for border controls. By April 2020, 93% of countries had implemented measures such as flight suspensions or border closures. The UK government only requested self-isolation for 14 days from high-risk areas and implemented no further measures until June 2020. Suspending flights from China in February could have provided "valuable additional time" to prepare healthcare systems, Baroness Hallett said.
When people were told to isolate, "many felt forgotten and let down by the lack of practical or financial support," the report states. Less than half complied with isolation rules in early months. The government introduced £10,000 fines for non-compliance, which experts said was counter-productive. Financial payments of £500 to help low-income earners comply were not introduced until September in England, later in Scotland and Wales.
The inquiry was more positive about digital contact tracing apps, citing a US modelling study suggesting that 75% uptake could reduce infections by at least 50%. Three separate apps were developed during Covid (one each for England/Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland/Republic of Ireland), which the inquiry said took up "valuable time." It recommends a single UK-wide digital tool for future outbreaks.
In summer 2021, around 7% of UK adults were told to self-isolate over seven days as restrictions eased, dubbed the "pingdemic" by press. Treasury estimates suggested this may have reduced economic growth by as much as 0.3% that month.